





Atlanta United finds itself in a state of disarray, marked by both leadership shifts and on-field underperformance. The recent departure of CEO Garth Lagerwey due to a cancer diagnosis has left a void, while head coach Ronny Deila struggles to find winning form, prompting questions about the team's future direction. Amidst these challenges, the possibility of former triumphant coach Tata Martino rejoining the club has emerged as a topic of considerable discussion.
Atlanta United Navigates Season of Struggles Amidst Coaching Speculation
The 2025 season has been particularly difficult for Atlanta United, highlighted by significant leadership changes and disappointing on-field results. In July, President and CEO Garth Lagerwey stepped away from his duties following a cancer diagnosis, leaving a leadership vacuum within the organization. Lagerwey, who had championed the current squad and personally advocated for first-year head coach Ronny Deila, oversaw a vision that has not materialized as hoped. Under Deila's guidance, Atlanta United has secured only five victories in 29 matches, prompting concerns about the team's ability to compete at an elite level.
Chris Henderson, the club’s Chief Soccer Officer and Sporting Director, appointed last December, now plays a pivotal role in shaping Atlanta's future. Henderson, who previously worked alongside Tata Martino in building a record-breaking Inter Miami squad, is now a central figure in decisions regarding the struggling team. His past association with Martino has naturally led to speculation about a potential reunion, given Martino’s availability and his successful tenure with Atlanta United, which culminated in an MLS Cup victory in 2018.
Martino, in a recent interview, acknowledged his strong affection for Henderson, stemming from their successful collaboration at Inter Miami. He described Henderson as an exceptional professional and person, with whom he maintains regular contact. Despite his emotional connection to Inter Miami, Martino indicated that his chapter with Atlanta United felt concluded after his two seasons, leading him to the Mexico national team job in 2019. However, he remains a highly respected figure among MLS teams seeking new leadership.
The current squad, despite significant investment, has largely underperformed. High-profile players have struggled to deliver, and the team's overall identity under Deila remains unclear. Miguel Almirón, who returned to Atlanta United after six seasons in the Premier League, has not been able to replicate his previous impact, struggling to find his form in a team that lacks cohesion. Martino, observing from a distance, highlighted the importance of a strong team foundation and player partnerships, which he believes are currently missing.
Following a crushing 5-4 defeat to the Columbus Crew, which saw Atlanta United eliminated from the MLS playoffs, Ronny Deila defiantly defended his position. Despite the team's dismal record and inconsistent tactics, the 49-year-old Norwegian coach expressed confidence in his ability to turn the team around for the 2026 season. He acknowledged the need for significant personnel changes, citing some players' lack of improvement or interest in doing so. However, Deila insisted that he maintains the support of his players and staff, vowing to prove skeptics wrong.
The team's poor performance, including conceding 54 goals and scoring only 36 in 29 matches, stands in stark contrast to the $50 million invested in new player acquisitions. The once-promising momentum from the end of the 2024 season has dissipated, leaving fans disillusioned. As Atlanta United grapples with these challenges, the question remains whether the club will continue to support Deila's vision or consider a return to its successful past with a familiar face like Tata Martino.
The current state of Atlanta United offers a compelling study in leadership, team dynamics, and the pursuit of success in professional sports. The struggles faced by Ronny Deila highlight the immense pressure on coaches to deliver results, even in the face of unforeseen circumstances like a CEO's absence. His defiant stance, while understandable, underscores the difficulty of maintaining morale and performance when a team is consistently underperforming. The narrative also brings to light the delicate balance between loyalty to a current coach and the potential strategic advantage of bringing back a proven leader. The speculation surrounding Tata Martino's possible return serves as a powerful reminder that past successes often cast a long shadow, prompting organizations to look to familiar, triumphant figures when navigating periods of significant challenge. Ultimately, Atlanta United's journey exemplifies the complex interplay of personnel, strategy, and intangible factors that define a team's trajectory.
